#Writing Fundamentals: One of Two Things Your #Novel May Lack
#Amwriting #WritingCommunity #Writers
(Beth Turnage Blog)
Coming Up Short? You May Be Skipping Your Character’s Feelings
I’ve been reading a novelist whose first two books have me looking at the story through my developmental editor’s lens. Occupational hazard. Once you spend enough time figuring out why a scene doesn’t work, it’s difficult to turn that part of your brain off.
What I’m seeing is a series of missed storytelling opportunities. Conversations that could develop the characters are summarized. Moments that could put the reader inside an experience are reported. And, most noticeably, the characters’ feelings receive so little exploration that the story moves past the very things that could make us care.
Things happen. The characters draw conclusions. On we go.
But hold on. What did that cost them?
This brings me back to a question I once answered on Quora: How do word count limitations affect what you can fit into a story?
After years of ghostwriting to a client’s word count, themes, and tropes, I’ve learned to work within a structure. I’m a structure gal. Knowing where the story needs to go frees me to work creatively inside it. But a word count can reveal another problem: you may be coming up short because you haven’t fully developed the story you already have.
Before you add another subplot, look at the feelings you’ve skipped.
You’ve Written the Conclusion. Where Is the Experience?
Suppose a character thinks:
Well, he’s obviously not into me.
That tells us what she believes. Depending on the context, it may even give us something of her voice. But if this is someone she badly wants, that conclusion deserves room. What did he say? What did she hear in it? Why does his apparent lack of interest hurt?
Here’s another way to approach the moment:
His words struck a wrong note, a twist in my gut that confirmed what I secretly thought. I’m not what he wants. My stomach soured.
I don’t know why what he wants matters so much to me.
No. Check that. I know, and I don’t want to admit that I might not be enough. When you want someone as badly as I do, that’s a thought that ruins your day.
Now we have something to work with.
The character first reacts to his words, then interprets them through a fear she already carries. She tries to distance herself from that fear, catches herself doing it, and admits something painful. His response matters because she has allowed his desire to become a judgment of her worth.
And notice: we still don’t know whether he actually wants her. We know what she believes. That difference gives the writer somewhere to take the scene.
The additional words do work. They expose desire, insecurity, and the character’s attempt to protect herself. They give readers access to a struggle they may recognize, even if their own circumstances are entirely different.
But the scene isn’t finished. What does she do with that feeling?
Feelings Belong in the Structure
When writers discuss narrative structure, we often concentrate on the large movements: the setup, the inciting incident, the midpoint, the major setback, the climax. I use those landmarks when I outline. Each chapter has a purpose in carrying the story toward the next one.
Inside those chapters, however, we need the connections that make the movement believable.
In my original Quora article, I described a sequence:
- The character observes something.
- The character has thoughts and feelings about that observation.
- The character responds through action or arrives at a conclusion that affects what comes next.
That middle step is easy to shortchange. The writer knows why the character is upset and assumes the reader will understand, too. Or the writer is so eager to reach the next plot point that the character barely has time to register what just happened.
But how a character understands an event determines the response.
Our character believes she isn’t wanted. Does she make a joke to hide her embarrassment? Leave before he can reject her explicitly? Ask a question whose answer she dreads? Pretend she has somewhere else to be?
Those choices lead to different scenes. They also tell us who she is.
If she pulls away, he may interpret that withdrawal as a lack of interest. Now her fear has helped create the very distance she dreaded. The emotional response has become part of the plot.
This is why exploring feelings matters to narrative structure. It supplies the reasons one event leads to another.
Give the Characters a Chance to Talk
Dialogue is another place where a manuscript can leave useful words unwritten.
“They talked about their relationship” gets us past the conversation. It doesn’t let us hear either person trying to navigate it.
What would happen if we stayed?
“You don’t have to stay,” I said.
He glanced toward the door. “I didn’t think you wanted me to.”
Of course he’d looked at the door. I’d handed him an exit and expected him to understand it was a question.
“That isn’t what I said.”
“Then tell me what you mean.”
Now the characters have something to contend with. She wants reassurance but makes an offer to leave. He takes her words seriously. She sees his glance through her fear of rejection. When he asks for clarity, she has to decide how much of herself to expose.
The conversation develops character while changing the situation. The interior response helps us understand what the spoken words cannot tell us by themselves.
You don’t need a confession in every conversation. Evasion can be revealing. So can an unfinished sentence, an answer to the wrong question, or a sudden insistence that everything is fine. Give the reader enough context to understand what the character risks by speaking honestly.
Let the Emotion Change
In the Quora article, I used a man named Jim who believes another golfer, Bob, cheated to impress their boss. Jim is angry, but there is something personal underneath: he wants the boss’s approval, too.
Bob walks into the bar and starts talking about the game. That gives Jim’s resentment a target. As the conversation develops, Jim’s anger escalates until he punches Bob. Afterward, facing the consequences, he feels ashamed.
The chapter has an emotional progression as well as a sequence of events.
To develop it, I would look for the point at which Jim’s control fails. What does Bob say that Jim cannot let pass? Does Jim hear a taunt that Bob intended, or does his own insecurity supply one? What warning does Jim ignore before he swings?
Then I would look at the shame. Is Jim ashamed that he lost control, frightened about his job, or still privately convinced Bob deserved it? Those possibilities can coexist. Their conflict gives the aftermath substance.
Writing “Jim was angry” and later “Jim felt ashamed” identifies the emotions. Exploring the movement between them gives us a chapter.
Use the Word Count to Find What’s Missing
A target word count helps me plan how much story I can tell. For example, a 60,000-word novel divided into twenty-five chapters averages 2,400 words per chapter. That is a planning tool, not a requirement that every chapter lands on the same number.
When a chapter comes in short, I ask whether I’ve done its work. Did I give the characters a meaningful exchange? Did I explore what the event threatens or promises? Did their response change the direction of the scene?
Sometimes, the chapter is complete at its shorter length. But then there are the times I’ve written the event and hurried past its consequences.
The answer isn’t to attach three paragraphs of emotional explanation to every action. A bodily sensation alone won’t carry the whole burden, either. A twisting gut tells us distress; the character’s thoughts and choices tell us what that distress means to this person.
Stay where something changes. Give that change enough space to register, then let the character respond.
Do the Work of the Chapter
Readers need reasons to stay with a character. Desire gives them something to hope for. Vulnerability gives them something to fear. A difficult choice makes them want to turn the page.
You create those connections by letting readers experience what matters to the character and watching that importance shape behavior.
So if your manuscript falls short of its intended word count, take another look before inventing a new complication. You may already have a conversation worth hearing, a reaction worth exploring, or a decision whose emotional groundwork you haven’t written.
“He’s obviously not into me” may be the conclusion.
What she does because she believes it is where the story goes next.
Next Article: The Second Thing Missing
Image created by ChatGPT, Graphics work by Beth Turnage